SUCCESS STORIES

Unexpected creative format boosts direct mail performance

INSURANCE SERVICES

Creative testing boosted acquisition sales rates by 30% for specialty insurer

After experiencing a decline in annual premium, this specialty insurer was looking for a partner to explore a new approach to direct mail creative. As a highly regarded brand in the industry, Franklin Madison Direct understood the importance of preserving this brand’s integrity within the direct mail channel. Working as an extension of the insurer’s in-house marketing group, FM Direct utilized direct response best practices to design more than five creative concepts. Although letter (envelope) packages traditionally outperform self-mailers in the insurance industry, initial testing identified a self-mailer as the best performing concept, beating the previous control package by a 12% sales rate. To continue optimizing the client’s direct mail program, FM Direct follows a regimented creative testing schedule in which new packages consistently boost performance metrics.

The Problem

Declining annual premiums prompted the insurer to seek a fresh approach to direct mail creative to drive higher response rates.

The Solution

FM Direct developed and tested 5+ creative concepts, uncovering a high-performing self-mailer format that outperformed traditional letter packages.

The Outcome

Acquisition sales rates grew 30%, production costs dropped 20%, and the new creative beat control by 12%.

INSURANCE SERVICES

Our Impact

1

Increase in Sales Rates

New creative concepts drove 30%+ higher acquisition sales rates.

1

Production Cost Reduction

Optimized direct mail formats cut production costs by 20%.

0

Higher Sales Rate

Self-mailer format beat the previous control package’s sales rate by 12%.

Through a close partnership with the client’s marketing team, we are able to translate their brand into compelling direct mail creative that drives measurable response and continued growth.

Ryan Wilder, Sr. Marketing Strategist, Seuel Response”

Tari Johnson, Creative Director, franklin madison direct

Data-driven direct mail optimization

FM Direct’s strategic direct mail testing methodology allows brands to quickly identify high-performing creative, offers, and audience segments. Using FactorTest, we test multiple variables—such as formats, messaging, and targeting models—within a single campaign to accelerate learnings and refine strategy.

By analyzing real-time results and scaling successful test components, FM Direct ensures brands maximize response rates while keeping costs efficient. This approach minimizes guesswork and delivers proven, scalable direct mail programs that drive long-term success.

Test smarter, scale faster

Success Stories

Discover how FM Direct helps financial companies outpace the competition and achieve measurable, winning results.

Modeling drives 50% AOV lift for home warranty brand

An established brand in the home warranty space had already experienced success with direct mail and wanted to elevate its mature program to new levels of growth. To continue to scale those wins, Franklin Madison Direct concentrated on routine data and format testing. A review of data suppression strategies identified 15% more records from the brand’s strongest prospect sources.

Read MoreModeling drives 50% AOV lift for home warranty brand

Investment brand unlocks high-quality leads with integrated direct response

After a successful launch into the mail channel, this meal delivery service was eager to maximize direct mail’s potential as a high-performing marketing channel. Franklin Madison Direct recommended merging the strengths of direct mail and digital advertising by reaching direct mail recipients through digital impressions before and during the mail delivery process via Surround™.

Read MoreInvestment brand unlocks high-quality leads with integrated direct response

BREAK THROUGH THE NOISE

Launch your next campaign with confidence

Start Your Test