As Seen on Forbes: Customer Acquisition In Financial Services Is Broken; Offline Data Can Fix It

Rising costs, privacy shifts, and declining signal quality are challenging the promise of digital-first acquisition in financial services. In his latest Forbes Agency Council article, Erik Koenig explores why offline data is becoming a critical advantage in driving higher-quality, more predictable growth. Read a sneak peek from the article below.

The following was originally published on Forbes Agency Council.

___________________________________________

When it comes to digital acquisition, financial services brands often chase efficiency. The idea is that broader data and reach, mixed with fast optimization, deliver better outcomes. However, many teams see the opposite: acquisition costs rise, approval rates fall, and consumers abandon applications despite initial strong intent.

My firm works closely with financial services brands, so I know these challenges aren’t just anecdotal. I’ve seen firsthand the patterns, behaviors, and strategies that reliably drive results.

While the problem may seem like demand, often it’s actually signal quality. When marketers lean into digital-first acquisition, they are forced to rely on temporary, probabilistic signals, such as cookie-based targeting that often disappears with privacy restrictions, click-and-view behavior, device or location signals, or look-alike modeling. These inputs may create volume, but they struggle to support the decisions the industry requires. Factors such as eligibility, risk tolerance, and long-term value rarely reveal themselves through clicks alone.

Why Digital Acquisition Lost Its Edge

In the regulated financial services category, several industrywide shifts are making it harder to sustain digital-only acquisition:

• Rising costs per thousand (CPMs) are forcing marketers to trade relevance for reach.
• Performance is harder to diagnose and optimize as privacy changes reduce transparency.
• Risk and compliance teams are left filtering applications that never should have entered the funnel.

Together, these pressures push acquisition engines toward scale without certainty. The result is budget waste, internal friction and customer journeys that break under their own weight.

___________________________________________

Keep reading on Forbes Agency Council to discover how offline data brings stability back to acquisition strategies—helping financial services brands focus less on volume and more on qualified, lasting relationships.